It is with no doubt that Nectar and Casper are huge brands when it comes to the sleep industry. These companies produce high-quality premium mattress and bedding products. Therefore, choosing the right mattress between the two can prove challenging.
Understand that, while these two mattresses perform incredibly well and share some common characteristics, they are pretty dissimilar in many aspects, including price, feel, and firmness. For example, the Casper mattress construction has a zoned support system responsible for offering a perfect balance of support and comfort. On the other hand, Nectar comes with memory foam offering unmatched comfort.
In case you are stuck on choosing between the Nectar vs Casper, this side by side comparison piece might enlighten you and offer some direction.
Nectar vs Casper Overview
Who Would Find Nectar Mattress Most Suitable?
- Sleepers who appreciate a memory foam mattress that gives them a hugging/sinking sensation of sleeping ‘in’ rather than ‘on’ the mattress.
- Couples who want a mattress that ultimately dampens any movements, i.e., high levels of motion isolation.
- People who yearn for premier luxury comfort at an affordable price.
- Hot sleepers who need a cooling mattress will love the Nectar.
- People who like long in-home trials and warranty.
Who Would Find The Casper Mattress Ideal?
- Sleepers who want an all-foam mattress that allows them to easily switch sleeping positions, thanks to its balanced foam feel.
- Combo sleepers, including those who frequently change sleeping positions while sleeping.
- Anyone who is looking for good pressure relief at the hip and shoulder region.
- Heavy people who require additional support.
- Couples who enjoy memory foam mattresses and the benefits of motion isolation and noise cancellation.
Similarities Between The Nectar and Casper
Both Nectar and Casper have some similar attributes. Such attributes may cause confusion between the two mattresses, so here are the comparisons:
- Firmness: The Nectar and Casper mattress are both considered to be a medium-firm feel.
- All foam construction: Both of these bed-in-a-box mattresses are constructed entirely of foam, and they are much gentler than an innerspring or hybrid mattress.
- Memory foam layer: Aside from the proprietary foams adopted by each manufacturer, both mattresses feature a layer of memory foam.
- Incredible pressure relieving properties: Both mattresses do a wonderful job when it comes to soothing sensitive points like hips, lower back, and shoulders.
- Similar support layer: In both the Nectar and Casper, you’ll find a high-density foam as their bases.
- Thickness: They both come in at 11-inches thick.
Differences Between The Nectar and Casper
There are glaring differences when comparing the Nectar mattress vs Casper. These notable differences include:
- Support system: You’ll find a zoned support system within the Casper mattress to offer targetted support and pressure relief efficiently throughout the body. By contrast, the Nectar mattress doesn’t have such a feature.
- Response rate: The Nectar mattress has a slow-moving memory foam feel, which usually causes sleepers to sink into the mattress slightly more. On the other hand, the Casper has a balanced foam feel that confers a little bounce to the mattress.
- Firmness: Although they are both considered to be medium-firm, when comparing the Casper vs Nectar, the Casper mattress has a slightly firmer profile than the Nectar.
- Price: Although each of the models falls under the mid-range price category, Casper is somewhat more affordable than the Nectar mattress.
- Warranty and sleep trial: Nectar offers a much longer warranty and sleep trial compared to Casper.
Nectar vs Casper: Mattress Construction
The Nectar Mattress Construction
Cover: The cover has quilting of memory foam, giving it a superbly comfortable and plush feel. When you lay on this mattress, you immediately get desirable comfort that is hard to deny.
Comfort layer: This layer comes immediately beneath the cover, and it begins with a gel-infused memory foam layer. This section has a slow response to pressure, making sleepers sink deeper for pressure relief at common pressure points, i.e., lower back, hips, and shoulders. The addition of cooling gel is to help mitigate the tendency of memory foam to heat up.
Transition layer: This is another memory foam layer, but with a quicker response to pressure than the above comfort layer. However, this layer’s major role is to continue the body contouring effect of the upper layers. This part of the mattress makes it ideal for side sleepers.
Base: This foundation foam is exclusively designed from high-density polyfoam, and is responsible for the bed’s shape and stability.
The Casper Mattress Construction
Cover: It’s designed from a knit polyester blend – thus, soft and cozy.
Comfort: This layer is made of open-cell foam, with a somewhat similar feel to latex, i.e., bouncy, naturally cooling, and responsive. This is very different from the comfort layer in a Nectar mattress.
Contour: This is the second layer and is designed from memory foam. As a result, it responds slowly to pressure and has a body contouring profile. Sleepers will, therefore, sink into the layer. However, its strategy beneath the top firmer layer ensures that sleepers do not sink much deeper.
Transition: The transition layer is designed to offer tailored support. It is zoned using two different foam types. The shoulders and feet area is made of softer foam, while the hip region utilizes firm foam for the much-needed lift. This arrangement establishes a balance that most back and side sleepers require.
Base: This is the final layer and is made from high-density polyfoam, just as in Nectar. It offers shape, durability, and stability.
Comparing Firmness and Feel
This section gives a sense of how these mattresses feel when you lie on them. However, it is worth noting that the final feel depends on individuals. Aspects like weight, body size, and body shape affect the feel.
Nectar mattress has a firmness score of 6.5/10, which is around about the standard rating for a medium firm. That makes it a softer mattress compared to the Casper. The Nectar contours to the body’s unique curves while not being too hard or too soft. It has a classic memory foam feel. Regarding sleeping positions, it should be a fine fit for side, back, and stomach sleepers.
On the contrary, Casper has a slightly firmer feel rating of 7/10 (although some heavy people may place it around 6.5/10), which makes it a little firmer than the standard medium-firm mattresses. Compared to Nectar, it offers a more balanced feel, which is great for both support and pressure relief. Back, side, and stomach sleepers will equally enjoy the feeling of this mattress. Combo sleepers who frequently switch positions at night will appreciate the fast responding foams, which allow for easy tossing and turning.
Nectar vs Casper: Performance
Both mattresses have good edge support. You get a secure feeling when you lie or sit on their edges. This is not very common with all-foam mattresses, so is a nice bonus, considering many of the others we have reviewed in the past of a similar price and composition didn’t rate so well.
In this aspect, Nectar handles motion somewhat better than Casper, making it a great choice for couples who argue about frequent disturbances caused by movements. The top memory foam is what isolates the motion. Casper is good at isolating movement between bed-sharing partners, but Nectar does it just a tad better.
Both mattresses are all-foam; therefore, they will no doubt trap a small amount of body heat. However, both have mechanisms to offset the buildup of excessive heat. Casper uses AirScape technology for effective heat dissipation, while Nectar has gel infusion and cooling Tencel cover. Neither seems to cause discomfort when it comes to hot nights.
Casper is a better option for sexually active partners as it is more bouncy and responsive to movement; you won’t feel trapped in the mattress.
Both of these mattresses perform very well in different ways for their pressure point relief. People with back and joint pain will like the Casper due to its slight push-back responsive foam and zonal design. Likewise, the plush yet supportive nature of Nectar’s gel memory foam offers a very soothing pain relief.
Warranty and Sleep Trial
Casper has a fairly standard 100-night sleep trial, while Nectar offers a somewhat rare and much longer period of 365-nights sleep trial. Likewise, the Casper warranty stands at 10 years for their mattress (industry standard for a memory foam mattress), while Nectar has a lifetime warranty.
The Final Word
In our opinion, when choosing a clear cut winner between the Casper vs Nectar, there isn’t one. Casper is more affordable and rates well in all of the criteria. Nectar is a tad more expensive but rates just as good on each of the above performance criteria. Nectar offers a longer warranty and trial, giving it that little edge. If we had to choose one, it would probably be with the flip of a coin.
Do neither of these mattresses seem like the right choice for you? We’ve conducted many more reviews and comparisons of all different types of mattresses for you to choose from.