Besides being bed-in-a-box online brands, Nectar and Tuft & Needle are somewhat comparable in terms of materials, construction, and firmness levels; there is plenty to distinguish them. Both feature thick layers of foam. Nectar has a thick adaptive foam making the top layer, resulting in decent pressure relief. At the same time, Tuft & Needle features premium foam that contours to your body curves while remaining responsive.
Realize that these are all-foam beds, and they promise one of the best sleeping experiences. However, shoppers can only choose one at a time. The preference for a particular mattress varies from sleeper to the next. The important thing is finding a mattress that betters your sleeping experience. To help you understand these mattresses, let’s break down essential features in this comparison between the Nectar vs Tuft and Needle mattress.
Nectar vs Tuft and Needle Overview
Tuft and Needle
The Nectar Mattress Might Be Ideal For?
- Sleepers preferring a classic memory feel, i.e., slow-moving memory that lets them get a hugging to feel while sleeping
- Side sleepers needing high levels of pressure relief at their shoulder and hips
- Couples needing to cut down motion transfer
The Tuft & Needle Mattress Might Be Ideal For?
- Individuals who want an affordable mattress or those who want to save on mattress purchases
- Sleepers who find it challenging to switch positions at night or those with mobility issues
- Sleepers seeking a balanced foam feel
Similarities Between The Nectar and Tuft & Needle
The similarities between these two beds are:
- They are both all-Foam beds: These two mattresses are designed entirely from foam. However, they offer a completely different sleeping experience since they feature different types of foam.
- Cooling relief: Both mattresses have covers featuring elements geared towards keeping the sleeper cool all night long. Nectar has Tencel and gel memory foam, while the T&N Mattress has Tactel, a moisture-wicking fabric.
- Affordable: While the T&N Mattress is the cheapest between the two, both are very affordable compared to similar mattresses yet very durable. So, when you purchase either of these, you get great value for your money.
Differences Between The Two Mattresses
- Comfort: Nectar Sleep utilizes thick memory foam resulting in sinkage and deep body contouring. By contrast, Tuft & Needle uses a bouncier proprietary foam that positions the sleeper on top of the mattress.
- Support: Nectar mattress has a transition layer to ease the sleeper into the firmer base, a feature absent in the Tuft & Needle. The result of this is a sleeper’s transition quickly to the firmer base, which may result in some discomfort.
- Thickness: Nectar is slightly thicker (11-inch) than the Tuft & Needle (10-inch)
Construction and Materials
Nectar mattress layers
Cover: The Nectar mattress cover is a blend of cotton and Tencel with admirable breathability and softness. The cover is quilted with a 1-inch layer of gel-infused memory foam to help mitigate the overheating.
Comfort Layer: This layer is made up of 3-inch-thick memory foam, and it sits beneath the cover, creating a decent comfort layer. The response to pressure from this memory foam is pretty slow. As such, it contours to the body shape and allows you to sink deeply into the mattress, providing satisfying pressure relief.
Transition Layer: Designed from a Hi Core 9.2 memory foam, the transition layer is a bit firmer and with a higher response to pressure than the upper layer. However, it still contours to the curves of sleepers. Its importance is to ease the sleeper into the firmer foundation safely.
Foundation Layer: The base is designed from 6-inch 5-pound high-density polyfoam. This layer offers a firmer foundation at that height and density and provides stability and shape to the mattress.
Tuft and Needle mattress layers
Profile: This mattress is 10 inches high and offers a balance between plush and firm.
Cover: Designed from a blend of polyester and Tactel, this cover has moisture-wicking properties; so, it dries quite quickly. Additionally, it is thin and stretchy, a design that allows free airflow into and out of your mattress.
Comfort Layer: This is a 3-inch proprietary foam layer. Though very soft, this layer has a quicker response to pressure; thus, giving a mix of support and pressure relief. Again, it is somewhat buoyant, making it easier to move or switch positions.
Foundation Layer: Standing at 7 inches high, this polyfoam layer works as the base of the mattress, offering support and giving shape to the entire mattress.
Firmness and Feel
The mattress’s firmness and feel are subjective as it varies with the sleeper’s size and weight distribution. However, most sleepers give both mattresses a similar firmness score on a scale of 1-10 (1 being the softest and 10 being the hardest). We’d say 6.5/10 for the Nectar, and 6.0/10 for the Tuft & Needle. This places them both at the centre of the scale, meaning they are both medium firm.
However, note that heavy people will have a different feel from lightweight individuals. The Tuft & Needle mattress has a balanced foam feel with a perfect balance of softness and responsiveness. Conversely, Nectar has a classic memory foam feel – it offers a little more sinkage.
Nectar Vs Tuft and Needle: Performance
Sinkage & Bounce
The Nectar mattress features adaptive memory foam, which allows the sleeper to sink into the mattress. This gives a feeling of sleeping “in” the mattress. That translates to less bounce. On the other hand, Tuft & Needle also sinks due to the absence of a transition layer, but the response to pressure is quicker; thus, sleepers have a feeling of sleeping “on” the mattress.
The thicker memory foam layer at the top of the Nectar mattress dampens the motion that sleepers might generate. So, it has better motion isolation properties than the Tuft & Needle meaning less movement will be felt by a bed-sharing partner using the Nectar.
Nectar has better edge support than the Tuft & Needle. Therefore, sitting or lying near the Nectar mattress’s bed edge gives you a more secure feel than that of the Tuft & Needle.
These mattresses feature some cooling properties and are all-foam beds, so they are even in this aspect. First, they’ll trap some heat. But the infusion of cooling materials prevents the foam layers from trapping the heat and making the bed hot at night.
The bouncy feel of the Tuft & Needle mattress makes it a better option for people who enjoy sex. Active movement will be met by a good, responsive motion.
When comparing the Tuft and Needle vs Nectar, there isn’t a great deal to set them apart. Both mattresses are all-foam, and they combine different layer sizes to offer comfort and support to sleepers of various kinds.
With its 5-layer design, Nectar is best at pressure relief but still supportive, especially side sleepers. Its relatively slow response to pressure means that sleepers sink into the mattress. By contrast, Tuft & Needle has a softer surface that transitions into a high-density base. It’s pretty bouncy, making it ideal for stomach and combo sleepers.
But, what is better Nectar or Tuft and Needle? In our opinion, we prefer the Nectar mattress due to its slightly more premium feel (which is of course reflected in the price) and overall value for money. It also provides somewhat better contouring, even though it’s ever-so-slightly firmer than the T&N. You’ll also get a 365-night trial period and a Forever Warranty with Nectar, as opposed to a 10-year warranty and a 100-night trial period with Tuft & Needle.
Do neither of these mattresses seem like the right choice for you? We’ve conducted many more reviews and comparisons of all different types of mattresses for you to choose from.