puffy vs nectar

Better Slumber is supported by our readers. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. For full details visit the disclosures page.

Puffy vs Nectar Mattress Comparison

Helen

Choosing between the Puffy vs Nectar mattress can be a daunting task, simply because these two mattresses feature the most admirable features within their categories.

Both are all-foam mattresses; thus, appealing to sleepers requiring good pressure point relief. To make them better for pressure relieving, both mattresses use a plush material for the cover and closest to the surface. So, throughout your sleep, you are guaranteed a feel of a luxurious sensation. Another standout feature that both the Puffy and Nectar mattresses offer is affordability and lifetime warranties.

Although the mattresses are quite similar, they are unique in their own rights. So, in this Nectar vs Puffy mattress comparison, we’ll look at the details of each one of them and discuss specifics side-by-side. Such detailed information helps make an informed choice when debating which mattress suits you between the two.

Puffy vs Nectar Overview

Puffy

Customer Rating
5/5

Nectar

Customer Rating
5/5

The Puffy Mattress

The Puffy mattress is a 10-inch mixed foam mattress offering an accommodating feel to a wide range of sleepers. Its standout features include:

  • Medium-firm profile (rating of 6/10)
  • A mid-range yet affordable mattress model
  • Suitable for average and lightweight sleepers of all sleeping positions

Who Should Consider The Puffy Mattress?

  • Combo sleepers: Especially side sleepers weighing less than 250 pounds will get the best results from Puffy.
  • Memory foam lovers: Sleepers who are used to the soft, hugging feel of memory foam will find this mattress comfortable.
  • Any bed surface: People needing a mattress that can work on any surface, such as a box spring, adjustable bed or slatted base will love the flexible compatibility Puffy offers.

The Nectar Mattress

The Nectar mattress is a 10-inch all-foam mattress featuring the following standout features:

  • A medium-firm profile (6.5 on a firmness scale of 1 to 10)
  • Excellent motion isolation, an admirable feature for couples
  • Suitable for sleepers of all kinds, i.e., different sleeping positions
  • Has features to ensure that there isn’t heat buildup – better temperature regulation than other memory foam mattresses

Who Should Consider The Nectar Mattress?

  • Couples: Couples require a mattress that can dampen all motions. Note that motion generated by a moving partner can interrupt sleep. Nectar can dampen such motion effectively.
  • Medium and heavy weight sleepers: The Nectar mattress has a medium-firm firmness making it perfect for average and plus-size sleepers. It’s currently made the list onto our top 5 “Best Mattress For Heavy People” roundups for 2021.
  • People in pain: Anyone suffering from joint or back pain will enjoy the support and pressure-point relief of the Nectar mattress.

Construction and Materials

Note that the types of materials and their arrangement within mattresses determine their overall performance. Additionally, it determines pricing, durability, and comfort.

Most all-foam mattresses feature multiple layers of different types of foam – typically, variations of memory foam, gel foam, and polyfoam. While memory foam is softer and body-conforming, polyfoam is denser and less pliable and confers the mattress’s support. Let’s take a look at the inner construction of the Puffy and Nectar.

Puffy mattress layers

The Puffy Mattress has three distinct layers, totaling up to 10-inches high. Here is the breakdown.

Cover: The cover is designed from pure polyester and has a soft and cozy feel. Additionally, it is removable and stain-resistant.

Comfort: Just beneath the cover, you’ll come into contact with the first comfort layer designed from the company’s Cooling Cloud™ memory foam. This area responds slowly to pressure, resulting in a contouring relief at the shoulders, hips, and lower back. This top layer cradles sleepers, making it suitable for people with joint pain. Since it features cooling gel infusion, this segment ensures that people don’t sleep hot.

Transition: This is a thin layer of polyfoam, and so you get a quicker response from this layer than the upper one when you exert pressure. Therefore, the transition layer’s role is to curb excessive sinkage and slowly ease the sleepers into the firmer base.

Base: This foundation layer features high-density polyfoam to support the above segments. Besides, it offers stability to the entire mattress structure.

Nectar mattress layers

Like the Puffy mattress, Nectar features three foam layers, totaling up to 11-inch high. Here are the details:

Cover: It’s designed from long-staple Tencel, and has quilting of one-inch gel-infused memory foam. Tencel is stretchy, soft, and sufficiently cool. What’s more, you can remove the cover for cleaning.

Comfort: This layer is made of gel memory foam – a material that responds slowly to pressure; thus, allowing the sleepers to sufficiently sink for contouring pain relief from aching joints. While sinkage is associated with heat buildup, the gel infusion counteracts this effect.

Transition: This is a firmer layer of adaptive hi-core memory foam, easing the sleeper to the firmer lower layer. It has a quicker response to pressure than the upper area, thus curbing the tendency to over-sink into the mattress.

Base: Designed from high-density polyfoam, this layer is responsible for the mattress’s stability and shape.

Side-By-Side Comparison

General Feel

Though they feature similar materials, these mattresses are very different in their composition. Their construction is pretty distinct. Both mattresses offer considerable sinkage, but the Puffy offers a deeper sinkage than the Nectar mattress because it has more memory foam than the Nectar and is slightly softer too. That makes Puffy a suitable option for people needing more cradling and hugging sensation or better pressure relief. So, it’s great for sleepers nursing joint pains and strict side sleepers. Nectar, being slightly firmer, is somewhat similar in feel but provides less “give” and feels more like you’re sleeping “on” the mattress rather than “in” the mattress.

Firmness

The Puffy is a medium-firm mattress with an average firmness rating of 6/10. Through the upper layers of memory foam, the two lower polyfoam layers bolster the mattress giving it the medium-firm profile. This makes it better for both side and back sleepers.

Puffy
Mattress firmness scale: 6 / 10

Nectar is a bit firmer than Puffy, with a rating of 6.5/10, making it on the slightly firmer side of medium-firm. Keep in mind; Nectar has a 5-inch memory foam layer, making it more supportive than the Puffy. The cradling ability makes it ideal for strict side sleepers or folks with joint pain.

Nectar
Mattress firmness scale: 6.5 / 10

Motion Isolation

Puffy has better motion isolating properties than Nectar, thanks to the thick memory foam top layer. However, both mattresses perform well in this aspect.

Temperature Regulation

Though designed from memory foam, these mattresses feature an infusion of gel which mitigates against the buildup of heat. That makes these mattresses temperature neutral. However, Puffy has more sinkage, which might cause a little heat, thus making the Nectar the cooler option.

Edge Support

These two mattresses score similarly in this category, as both have a fairly firmer edge. So, even if you sleep on their edge, you won’t feel like falling off the bed.

Warranty

Each company has a detailed fine print when it comes to dealing with a warranty. However, in terms of comparable length, both score the same as you’ll get a lifetime warranty with the Puffy and the Nectar mattress.

Sleep Trial

Puffy is offering 101 nights to try the mattress in the comfort of your home, whereas Nectar is offering a much longer 180 nights.

The Final Word

The Nectar mattress is a great choice for people needing to relieve pressures at joints such as the hips, lower back, and shoulders. In our opinion, the Nectar does a better job at reducing pressure than the Puffy mattress, being the slightly firmer and supportive option. Again, if you are a side sleeper, this should work well for you.

Puffy is a suitable choice for active combo sleepers and back sleepers. Being softer than Nectar, the Puffy mattress is a very plush and luxurious feel, and as they describe on their website, it’s like sleeping on a cloud. Yet, it still provides perfect contouring and spinal alignment.

To be honest, when comparing Puffy vs Nectar in terms of performance in the above categories, there really isn’t much between them.

Still Undecided?

Do neither of these mattresses seem like the right choice for you? We’ve conducted many more reviews and comparisons of all different types of mattresses for you to choose from.