Puffy and Purple are among some of the best when it comes to bed-in-box mattresses. Both have been boasting a strong online presence for a number of years. The standout feature of both of these foam mattresses is their ability to provide great comfort and relieve pressure at the same time.
Puffy is an all-foam (memory foam) mattress, which explains why it has decent pressure relieving properties. People having back pain or joint pain might find this mattress a suitable option. Also, to deal with hot sleepers, within the comfort layer, free airflow channels prevent heat build-up by allowing it to dissipate away.
By contrast, Purple boasts of its innovative Purple Grid, which is a hyper-elastic polymer grid that defines the mattress’s comfort layer. In addition to contouring your body for pressure relief, this layer is also effective in temperature regulation.
Choosing the best when comparing the Puffy vs Purple depends on how deep you understand their anatomy and comparing them to your sleeping needs. That’s what this review looks at – typically, we compare the major aspects, i.e., material and construction, and performance.
Puffy vs Purple Overview
The Puffy mattress is made entirely of foam, i.e., a mix of memory foam and polyfoam. Its standout features include:
- Lifetime warranty to buyers.
- The foam layers are excellent at relieving pressure and cushioning pressure points.
The Purple mattress is an extremely comfortable choice, coming with innovative technology. It’s ten inches thick and has three layers. Its standout features include:
- The flexing of the Purple Grid under your weight results in a remarkable cradling effect.
- Airflow channels important in temperature regulation
- Though it has a notable bounce, it properly isolates motion.
Who Should Buy The Puffy Mattress?
- Light to medium weight side sleepers who don’t need much support but are looking for a fair amount of pressure relief at the shoulder and hip region
- Back sleepers looking for cradling feel of memory feel
- Light-to medium-weight back sleepers who like a memory foam feel
- Sleepers looking for a balanced foam feel with a touch of memory foam on top
Who Should Buy The Purple Mattress?
- Heavy side sleepers looking for advanced pressure relief at the hip and shoulder region
- Heavy-weight back sleepers needing extra support for a better spinal alignment
- Hot sleepers
Puffy vs Purple: Similarities
These two mattresses have some common features, which include:
- Foam construction: Both mattresses are constructed entirely of foam, while Purple also features a hyper-elastic polymer layer besides the foam layers.
- Shipping type: Both are bed-in-a-box mattresses, which makes delivery and setup not only cheaper but easier too.
- Durability: The mattresses boast thick high-density polyfoam layers that give them stability and much-needed support and also reduces deterioration.
- A similar price range: Though prices may vary from one week to another, their price is usually similar and generally ranges from $500 to about $1300. Always check out for the latest prices.
Material and Construction
Here, we take a look into the structure of these mattresses. Ideally, we look at the arrangement of layers and how it influences the performance of the mattress.
Puffy Mattress Layers
Cover: The puffy mattress cover features pure polyester; thus, a flexible cover with comfortable stretch
Comfort: This layer is called the Cooling Cloud Foam layer – a mere 2-inch-thick layer of gel memory foam. The layer offers decent pressure relieving properties, but most importantly, the gel infusion dissipates heat ensuring you sleep cool.
Transition: This another 2-inch-thick layer but made of high-density polyfoam. This confers a firmer feel than the upper layer but still cradles the body. It’s firmer, therefore, having a quicker response to pressure – hence, preventing from sinking.
The base: It is 6-inches thick and designed from high-density polyfoam – denser than the transition layer. It is responsible for the shape and stability of the mattress.
Purple Mattress Layers
Cover: The cover is designed from a blend of Lycra and polyester with a viscose touch, resulting in a thin breathable surface. Note that viscose is semi-synthetic, and it aids in making you sleep cool.
Comfort: This is a 2-ich thick proprietary hyper-elastic polymer material responsible for the bounce that the mattress offers. Typically, sleepers get a quick response to pressure, but its grid structure collapses to your body pressure at the hip and shoulder for contouring pressure relief. However, the other areas retain their integrity.
Transition: This a 3.25-inch thick and slightly firmer, and higher density than the comfort layer. The increased density is to ensure it doesn’t sink too much. Nonetheless, it cradles a little but offers full-body support.
Base: This layer is 4-inch thick and is simply high-density polyfoam – firmer than the transition layer. Its primary role is to offer foundational support, stability, and durability.
Comfort and Feel
Puffy is a standout comfortable mattress that seems to be a good fit for most people. It’s a plush feel with a medium-firm firmness level. Nonetheless, it falls short when it comes to offering support to stomach sleepers. Sleepers will feel the comfort initially, but they may sink a little with time, especially if weighing more than 200 lbs, causing misalignment of hips and lower back. However, back and side sleepers will get along just fine with the Puffy.
By contrast, Purple mattress offers a balanced feel to sleepers. So, if you don’t know your sleeping needs, this could be the right mattress. Ideally, you’ll get some great lift and bounce, thanks to the grid-like comfort layer. With the bounce, you get better mobility, which means easy switching positions during the night and when it comes to playful nighttime activities. Although still classed as a medium-firm mattress, it’s slightly on the firmer side compared to Puffy.
Joint and Back Pain
Both of these mattresses perform extremely well when it comes to pressure point relief. The Purple uses its collapsing grid-like foam to contour and align the spine, hips, and shoulders, which it does very well indeed. Likewise, the Puffy mattresses use a medium-firm gel-infused foam to cradles and support the body effortlessly while still providing a cloud-like experience.
Motion isolation is a great feature for couples or if you have a sleeping partner. Puffy has better motion isolation potential than Purple mattress due to the thick memory foam layer that absorbs/dampen all the movements. Purple is a little bouncy and therefore transfers some motion to sleepers close to each other. However, in a King size, nothing is likely to be felt on the other side of the bed.
Like other foam mattresses, the Puffy is not great when it comes to edge support. In contrast, the Purple is much better. Along with the Purple Grid, there is a 3-inch foam encasement, which enhances edge support. This implies that sleepers can maximize the mattress’s entire surface without the worry of tipping off when they near the edge. Therefore, when comparing the Purple vs Puffy, Purple comes out on top in this criteria.
Off-Gassing and Smell
Both mattresses emit a slight odor right out of the box. But this should disappear within 48 hours. The Puffy smells a bit worse to begin with due to its higher amount of foam content.
If you sweat a lot while sleeping at night, you need a mattress with better temperature regulation potential. In this case, the Purple mattress is the winner as the grid construction alongside a thin breathable cover for airflow works exceptionally well at reducing the build-up of heat. This makes the mattress temperature neutral. Puffy being an all-foam mattress, doesn’t have much breathability. The gel content in the Puffy mattress is better than most memory foam mattresses in its class, but the Purple has the slight edge here.
Most people prefer a bouncy mattress when it comes to enjoying sex. in this case, the Purple mattress performs best. However, many people still prefer the contouring and hugging feeling of memory foam, which also provides good traction. In which case, Puffy wins. The choice is really bounce over traction, and down to personal preference.
The Final Word
If you are a fan of the traditional memory foam feel, a Puffy mattress might be your perfect choice. Similarly, if you want a cloudy/hugging feel, Puffy might work for you. It is soft yet supportive and comes with a lifetime warranty.
However, if you are a combo sleeper, or you need a mattress that offers bounce and lets you sleep ‘on’ rather than ‘in’ the mattress, the Purple is the way to go.
Do neither of these mattresses seem like the right choice for you? We’ve conducted many more reviews and comparisons of all different types of mattresses for you to choose from.