Best Crib Mattress

Better Slumber is supported by our readers. If you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. For full details visit the disclosures page.

Top 6 Best Crib Mattress Roundup For 2022

Better Slumber

When it comes to their kids, parents don’t leave any stone unturned. They want to give their utmost and buy the finest for their children. From nutrition to clothing, parents naturally always strive to provide the cream of the crop for their kids. So why should they leave something as important as a proper sleeping set-up to chance? In particular, we mean the mattress that your baby sleeps on within their crib.

The crib mattress is an important part of your baby’s health and mental build-up. As adults, we all know the value of a good night’s sleep. When your baby has a comfortable sound sleep, they are refreshed and can start their day with a healthy and happy frame of mind.

So, are you one of these parents that realize the importance of quality products? Are you actively looking for the best crib mattress that you can find? If so, without further ado, let’s dive right in and discuss our roundup of the five top crib mattresses for 2022.

Our Favorite Pick

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams crib mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams

Water Resistant, Lightweight, Hypoallergenic, & GreenGuard Certified
Editor's Pick

Best Crib Mattress (Top 6 Roundup)

Online Deals Validated
Sources Researched
Hours Of Research
Crib Mattresses Evaluated

Here’s our top picks at a glance

Crib Mattress Reviews

Here is a roundup of the 6 best mattress for toddlers and babies reviewed, based on our research and findings.

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams crib mattress

Safety First Heavenly Dreams

The Safety First Heavenly Dreams is probably the safest crib mattress around in 2022. You may have seen some baby mattresses that feature the GREENGUARD GOLD certification. But what does it mean? This certification stands for products that have a very low chemical emission in the indoor air due to its usage. Another important piece of information is, this product is completely free of phthalates and lead. That means it is not toxic at all.

The Safety 1st crib mattress is waterproof, lightweight, and hypoallergenic. That means what you get is a perfect sleeping surface for the toddler in your household.

One of the key features of the crib mattress is that it is water-resistant. This is especially critical because whether it’s potty training or milk spills, they can happen at any point in time. A waterproof crib mattress will last much longer than one, which isn’t. Also, the mattress is hypoallergenic means it does not allow dust mites and dust to settle inside the mattress. As a parent, you would always want to have the top option for your baby. Therefore, the mattress that a child sleeps in must be hypoallergenic. Dust mites prime reasons for dust-related allergies and also shorten the mattress lifespan.

The Heavenly Dreams fits a standard crib with internal measurements of 28⅝ inches x 53 inches. The mattress dimensions will fit most standard cribs, and the weight limit is 50 lb.

Last but not least, it’s worth noting that Safety 1st received the Women’s Choice Award as America’s Most Recommended brand for Baby Crib & Toddler Mattress; not something you see very often from such a competitively priced product.

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress

Graco Premium Foam

There are several reasons why we like the Graco Premium Foam crib and toddler mattress. One of the primary complaints is that most crib mattresses don’t come with a removable or washable outer cover. The Graco Premium Foam crib mattress comes with one. You can easily unzip it and wash it at your convenience. The material is 100% polyester and easily washable.

The fact that it is water-resistant also adds to the list of advantages. With a couple of toddlers around your home, you know how quickly things can go south at any time. Not only do you have to worry about accidents with poop and wee, but sometimes splashing water, trying to emulate a favorite cartoon character, or an accidental spilling while trying to water the potted plants on the window, anything can happen. Toddlers are highly imaginative and highly energetic. Accidents can happen at any time, and it is good to know that your baby mattress is safe under the water-resistant outer cover.

The second significant advantage is that the Graco crib mattress comes shipped in a compressed form for easy transportation. Once you receive the delivery, you must unpack and unroll it for expansion. Make sure you do that at room temperature for perfect results.

It’s worth noting that this mattress has been awarded the 2020 Women’s Choice Award for 9 out of 10 Customer Recommended Crib & Toddler Mattress.

Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

Milliard Hypoallergenic

When compared to adults, babies and toddlers require slightly different support when sleeping. And this is where mattresses like the Milliard Hypoallergenic baby crib mattress come into the picture. It offers a mix of support and comfort that is perfect for your young ones.

And don’t forget waterproofing. Accidents can happen, and you need to have the right mattress that can withstand any urine, milk, vomit, and almost any other liquid spillage. The Milliard Hypoallergenic crib mattress comes with a waterproofing cover that ensures that no matter what, it will not get damaged.

We know that we try to keep our children in a safe and protected environment. And that means no fire in the house and certainly no playing with the electrical systems. But what happens when they are on their own? One of the critical things that can enrage a fire in your home is a flammable material like a mattress. The Milliard Hypoallergenic baby mattress is made from CERTIPUR certified foam. It complies with the Federal anti-flammability requirements.

As babies quickly become toddlers, you can expect a lot of jumping up and down in their cribs. The mattress bears much of the brunt of all that. While any other cheap crib mattress would quickly wilt and lose shape, despite the competitive and appealing price of the Milliard mattress, it stays true to shape and maintains its comfortable performance.

Dream On Me Twilight

Dream On Me Twilight

When it comes to choosing the best baby mattress, it is important to ensure that it comes with a support system that maintains the overall structural rigidity. Many crib mattresses lose their shape over time. In this case, the Dream On Me Twilight 5″ 80 coil innerspring crib mattress has about 80 interwoven steel coils along with a 6-gauge steel border wire around the entire perimeter of the mattress. This is the support system of the mattress.

The Dream On Me crib mattress features a reversible design. That means there are 2 levels of support on the mattress. On one side, you have what is called the infant side (an optimal firm support system), and on the flip side, you’ll find added cushioning comfort for a toddler.

Sadly, the cover isn’t removable but can be spot cleaned with soap and water. The triple laminated waterproof cover resists stains and leakages from getting inside. Also, added air pockets within the core allow this breathable crib mattress to promote freshness.

The entire manufacturing technology is US-made. The product is made of completely non-toxic materials, which are both environmentally friendly and perfect for the sleeping patterns of a toddler. Oh, and did you know that the Twilight mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified? This ensures that you get the perfect choice in terms of safety and health for your little ones.

Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer

Why should you have to change your mattress when your infant grows up to be a toddler? Wouldnt it be great if you could simply flip it over and keep using it? The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer dual-sided crib mattress is a flippable design. That means it comes with two different levels of comfort on the two sides of the mattress. There is the Extra Firm side for babies, and then there is the reverse Plush side, perfect for toddlers and aging kids. That means you can use this infant mattress for a few years till your children outgrow their crib.

The Moonlight Slumber is a lightweight foam-core construction. It is extremely easy to clean. The mattress itself comes in a waterproof vinyl case: the top surface is water-resistant, which means it can resist any liquid such as milk, urine, or other spillages. Unfortunately, you cannot remove that case. But in the incident of any spillage, you can simply wipe it down or wash it off without any issues. If you feel the need for extra protection, you can buy a separate waterproof cover, and it will also work as your mattress protector, but this isn’t really necessary. All in all, there should not be any water-related damages. One more vital feature of this product is it is odor resistant.

The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer comes in a relatively standard crib mattress size ().

Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib and Toddler Mattress

Delta Children Twinkle Stars

Why settle for something ordinary when you can buy the best for your children. The fiber-core Delta Children waterproof lightweight crib mattress is a great choice for your toddlers when they are sleeping.

The mattress is GreenGuard Gold certified, which ensures that the product releases zero toxins in the air on account of its use. That also means there are fewer chances of diseases in your home.

A mattress does not have to be heavy to provide firm support for your toddler. Mattresses such as Delta are perfect examples of how lightweight materials can also provide firm support for your children so that when they sleep on them, they get a good night’s sleep. According to the manufacturer, the Twinkle stars model weighs approx 9 pounds. Now, we have seen much lighter baby mattresses, but 9 pounds is still very light when moving the crib around or changing sheets.

With children at home, there’s always a chance of water spillage or accidents where liquids are spilled on the mattress. If it is not waterproof, it will sustain a considerable amount of damage and maybe no longer usable. The Delta Children crib mattress is waterproof, and therefore there are no such risks due to water spillage.

Best Baby Crib Mattress Buying Guide

best crib mattress reviews

Let’s quickly look at the main considerations when buying a mattress for your baby crib.

Type Of Material

The inner construction or core of the mattress is something that many people overlook when choosing a baby bed mattress. Mostly, you will find either spring or foam. An innerspring crib mattress is very durable, breathable, keeps the baby cool, and has less chance of mold or mildew forming. They are heavier and are unlikely to be delivered compressed and rolled in a box. A foam crib mattress is much lighter, will most likely be fully waterproof, and will probably be delivered compressed and rolled into a box. Although it will probably lose shape quicker than a spring crib mattress, it will be fine for a baby to toddler transition for sure. If you’re planning on having a few kids in succession and want to reuse the mattress, an innerspring might be better.

Type Of Cover

Although it’s nice to have a breathable organic cotton cover that is beautiful and soft for your baby, it isn’t the most practical. We’d always recommend a laminated or vinyl outer cover. This type of material is waterproof and can be wiped clean easily. This type of outer cover is unlikely to be removable, whereas a cotton/polyester cover may be removable and washable.


The firmness or “feel” of a crib mattress determines more than just how comfortable your infant will be while sleeping. The firmness ultimately determines the support that it will provide to your child’s body. A supportive mattress means the spine will be aligned properly, and a healthy back for children means fewer back-related problems as they grow older.


The next important aspect that you have to consider is whether it’s a waterproof mattress not. The best crib mattress will always be one that’s waterproof. All the mattresses that we have discussed here are fully waterproof or at least water-resistant. As you can imagine, fluid-related accidents can happen at any time. For example, your baby’s diaper comes loose, or milk spills from the bottle; there is always a chance of spillage. Liquid can soak into your baby mattress, damaging it permanently. Thankfully, a lot of the manufacturers use waterproof material, which ensures that in the event there is water spillage, the mattress is not badly damaged.

Crib Size

The crib mattress size is a very important factor that cannot be overlooked. Most that are termed “crib mattress” will fit standard cribs and toddler beds and will be approx 27.5 “W x 52 “L x <6” H. Be sure to measure the inner dimensions of your crib to ensure it is a standard size and can accommodate the standard crib mattress dimensions.

Flippable Design

Dual sided, otherwise known as flippable designs, are the same mattress with 2 different levels of firmness and support on the two sides. Usually, there is a firm side and a soft side. The firmer side is ideal for infants. This is also the side that needs waterproofing because of the high chances of water spillage. Then there is the softer side. You have to flip the mattress to use the side you prefer. The softer side is perfect for toddlers who need a little bit of cushiony comfort.

What happens is that if you buy a 2-sided flippable crib mattress for your infant, it is going to last from baby to toddler years. Once the baby stage is crossed you can simply flip over the mattress and use the firm side for the toddler to sleep on. So, one mattress does the job of 2 and saves you a considerable amount of money in the process.


We have already emphasized the importance of the GreenGuard Gold certification, especially in the context of a baby crib mattress. As the mattress will be placed in your child’s room, you don’t want it to get polluted because of suspended particles that are released from the mattress when it is in use. Also, the mattress should be free of toxins. GreenGuard Gold certification ensures that the indoor air quality remains safe for you and your baby. Also, it will ensure the product is free of phthalates and lead.

Another certification that is almost mandatory, especially when buying a memory foam crib mattress, is the CertiPur US seal. Similar to the GreenGurad, it confirms the foam used within the mattress to be non-toxic and safe.

Lastly, you may come across the JPMA certification. This seal signifies that products manufactured for juveniles in today’s marketplace meet minimum government requirements based on safety.

Trial Period

With most full size mattresses, you get a free trial period to test the mattress at home. This isn’t usually the case with baby mattresses. If your mattress comes with a money-back guarantee or a free trial period of some sort, this is a nice bonus.


One last parameter you need to consider is whether the manufacturer is offering you a warranty, and if so, for how long. The last thing you want is to buy a crib mattress with the intention of using it for a few siblings throughout the years, but find that it had reached its end of days long before you expected.


As a parent, you always want to give the finest products to your children, and that is quite natural. So why make a compromise when you want to buy a mattress for your child? As we have stressed in this discussion, a good quality mattress means a lot to anybody. Not just a baby or toddler. Because when you have a good quality mattress, you are guaranteed a good night’s sleep. Therefore, you must always choose the best, and we recommend that you look at the parameters that we have discussed here.

Look for the Green Guard Gold certification because it is very important. Look for waterproofing. And most importantly, look for a size that fits your crib perfectly. Hopefully, the following suggestions will help you to choose the best toddler mattress that will help your child to sleep soundly for years.